Companies fined combined £120,000 after man suffers serious injuries

Two construction companies have been fined a combined total of £120,000 after a groundworker suffered horrific injuries when heavy drainage pipes fell on top of him.

Anthony Pennell was rushed to Royal Stoke University Hospital having sustained several fractures to both sides of his pelvis, as well as a fractured vertebrae and bleed on the spine, following the incident at a site in Fradley Park, Lichfield on 3 September 2019.

Mr Pennell, who was 32 at the time, spent nine days in hospital before he was able to be discharged to his home in Cleethorpes.

The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) has guidance about the regulations on lifting operations and equipment.

“I had to sleep downstairs for about five months after the accident and I could only use the downstairs toilet,” he said.

“I had a lot of help from my partner Zoe who was allowed a period of time off work which lasted for the first 14 days after I came home.

“She helped me with washing and changing my clothes. She brought everything that I needed to me because I could only mobilise with difficulty and using two crutches and therefore, I couldn’t carry anything.”

HSE enforcement lawyer Nathan Cook,  told Telford Magistrates’ Court how Mr Pennell, an employee of R O Donnell Plant & Civil Ltd, sustained his injuries. The pipes ,each weighing around 160 kg, had been suspended on the forks of a telehandler while being moved to a different area of the site.

Although one pack of pipes had already been transported safely, the incident happened while moving a second load. When the telehandler came to a stop, Mr Pennell tried to re-position a dangling skid so that the pack could be lowered properly. However, at this point, the load fell on top of him.

Four years on, the 37-year-old has not been able to resume his job as a groundworker, and is instead only able to work as a landscaper, which pays him less.

“I continue to have pain in my right leg,” he said. “I am no longer as strong as I was and can no longer carry out heavy manual activities.

“I will always be at a disadvantage in the labour market, and cannot see how I could get a job again where I would earn the money that I was earning as a groundworker.”

An investigation by HSE found that both Mr Pennell’s employer and the principal contractor (Readie Construction Ltd) failed to ensure that the operation was properly planned, appropriately supervised, and carried out in a safe manner. The investigation also identified issues in relation to the level of knowledge and experience of those involved in the lifting operations, and in the companies’ overall management and coordination of the telehandler usage between contractors.

R O Donnell Plant & Civil Ltd, of New Road, Worlaby, Brigg, Lincolnshire, pleaded guilty to breaching 8(1) of the Lifting Operations and Lifting Equipment Regulations 1998 and was fined £80,000 and ordered to pay costs of £3,784.

Readie Construction Ltd, of Falcon Business Centre, Ashton Road, Romford, Essex, pleaded guilty to breaching 8(1) of the Lifting Operations and Lifting Equipment Regulations 1998 and was fined £40,000 and ordered to pay costs of £3,784.

HSE inspector Will Gretton said: “This horrific incident could easily have been avoided had the work been properly planned and suitable control measures implemented to properly secure and safely transport the load.

“This case should remind all on construction sites and wider industry that all lifting operations must be properly planned by a competent person, appropriately supervised and carried out in a safe manner to ensure the health and safety of those involved or affected by the work.”

HSE

September 2023

What we think

Lifting Operations in construction is a well-known, high-risk hazard that needs to be carefully considered and controlled. Where lifting is undertaken on site using lifting equipment, due consideration should be given to:

  • Planning the lift
  • Using competent people with appropriate training and experience
  • Supervising the lift
  • Implementing a Safe System of Work

Accidents at work are unplanned events, however, having the above in place should reduce the risk of an accident or incident occurring. Hindsight is a wonderful thing and in this case, if the lifting and work had been properly planned, the injured worker may not have been involved in the accident which has caused him ongoing health and financial issues, which are undoubtedly affecting his mental health too.

How we can help

Wiser Safety have a variety of solutions available including:

  • Provision of Competent Safety Partner Services to ensure compliance with current legislation
  • Review of existing Policies, Procedures and Safe Systems of Work
  • Development of Safe Systems of Work including suitable and sufficient Risk Assessments
  • Provision of appropriate Training
  • Regular Site Safety Inspections

Please get in touch if you would like to discuss a workable solution for your business. Please feel free to Call Us on 01732 446503 or Message Us